Global Breaking News - Sunday, December 22, 2024

Can the Minimum Wage Be Too High?
On Monday, Seattle’s City Council voted to raise the local minimum wage gradually to $15 an hour, more than twice the federal minimum wage and one of the highest anywhere in the nation. Can the economy support such a raise? Will elevating the pay floor lead to job losses or will it be a boon for the city and an example for national reform?
* city council = 시의회/ minimum wage = 최저 임금/ gradually = 서서히/ boon = 득, 혜택/ reform = 개혁, 개선

 경제가 최저 임금의 인상을 떠받칠 수 있나요? 최저 임금 인상로 일자리가 줄까요 아니면 도움이 될까요?

1. Workers Will Suffer in the Long Run
Employees are likely to be gradually replaced by self-order kiosks that use touchscreens instead of cashiers in restaurants, and self-scanning checkout booths in drugstores and supermarkets.

2. Overcoming the New Low-Wage Economy
When workers have more, they can spend more and need less assistance. Employers will adjust, and studies show little effect on employment.

3. Not the Best Anti-Poverty Tool
The minimum wage treats workers the same whether they are adults heading a household or teens from upper middle-class families working a part-time job.

4. Well-Paid Workers Strengthen Local Economies
The most insidious part of trickle down isn’t that if the rich get richer, that’s good for the economy. It is that if the poor get richer, that will be bad.

5. Finally a Chance for Facts to Decide
The somewhat long ramp-up period in Seattle will provide us with an occasion to learn from this economic policy and offer opportunities for course corrections.


Sample Essay

Overcoming the New Low-Wage Economy

By raising its minimum wage to $15, Seattle is leading a long-overdue movement toward a living wage. Most minimum wage workers aren't teenagers these days. They're major breadwinners who need a higher minimum wage in order to keep their families out of poverty.

Across America, the ranks of the working poor are growing. While low-paying industries such as retail and food preparation accounted for 22 percent of the jobs lost in the Great Recession, they’ve generated 44 percent of the jobs added since then, according to a recent report from the National Employment Law Project. Last February, the Congressional Budget Office estimated that raising the national minimum wage from $7.25 to $10.10 would lift 900,000 people out of poverty.

Seattle estimates almost a fourth of its workers now earn below $15 an hour. That translates into about $31,000 a year for a full-time worker. In a high-cost city like Seattle, that’s barely enough to support a family.

The gains from a higher minimum wage extend beyond those who receive it. More money in the pockets of low-wage workers means more sales, especially in the locales they live in – which in turn creates faster growth and more jobs. A major reason the current economic recovery is anemic is that so many Americans lack the purchasing power to get the economy moving again.

With a higher minimum wage, moreover, we’d all end up paying less for Medicaid, food stamps and other assistance the working poor now need in order to have a minimally decent standard of living.

Some worry about job losses accompanying a higher minimum wage. I wouldn’t advise any place to raise its minimum wage immediately from the current federal minimum of $7.25 an hour to $15. That would be too big a leap all at once. Employers – especially small ones – need time to adapt.

But this isn’t what Seattle is doing. It’s raising its minimum from $9.32 (Washington State’s current statewide minimum) to $15 incrementally over several years. Large employers (with over 500 workers) that don’t offer employer-sponsored health insurance have three years to comply; those that offer health insurance have four; smaller employers, up to seven.

My guess is Seattle’s businesses will adapt without any net loss of employment. Seattle’s employers will also have more employees to choose from – as the $15 minimum attracts into the labor force some people who otherwise haven’t been interested. That means they’ll end up with workers who are highly reliable and likely to stay longer, resulting in real savings.

Research by Michael Reich (no relation) and Arindrajit Dube confirms these results. They examined employment in several hundred pairs of adjacent counties lying on opposite sides of state borders, each with different minimum wages, and found no statistically significant increase in unemployment in the higher-minimum counties, even after four years. (Other researchers who found contrary results failed to control for counties where unemployment was already growing before the minimum wage was increased.) They also found that employee turnover was lower where the minimum was higher.

Not every city or state can meet the bar Seattle has just set. But many can – and should.